Florida Estate & Trust Litigation Blog

Trusts & Estates

What happens when a child is born after an estate plan was already prepared?

Litigation Over Pretermitted Children From Estate Plans

In Florida, a child born or adopted after their parent executes a Will is called a Pretermitted Child an may inherit a significant portion of their parent’s estate. Florida Statutes Section 732.302 defines pretermitted children as follows:

When a testator omits to provide by will for any of his or her children born or adopted after making the will and the child has not received a part of the testator’s property equivalent to a child’s part by way of advancement, the child shall receive a share of the estate equal in value to that which the child would have received if the testator had died intestate, unless:

(1) It appears from the will that the omission was intentional; or

(2) The testator had one or more children when the will was executed and devised substantially all the estate to the other parent of the pretermitted child and that other parent survived the testator and is entitled to take under the will.

The share of the estate that is assigned to the pretermitted child shall be obtained in accordance with s. 733.805.

Applicable Case Law:

On April 9, 2014, a Florida court decided a unique issue relating to children omitted from their parent’s Will.

The Case:  Estate of Maher v. Iglikova, 138 So. 3d 484 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2014).

The issue: Is a child pretermitted when she is born before the Will was executed but not legitimized until after?

Florida’s Third District Court of Appeals answered that question in the negative.

In 2009, the decedent, James P. Maher, was declared deceased five years after his disappearance from Florida. His last will and testament dated July 11, 2001 was admitted to probate.

The decedent had two children— a son born in April of 1999 and a daughter born in December of 2000. He was unaware of his daughter’s existence until 2002.

The daughter’s mother, on behalf of the daughter, contested the Will and brought an action to have the daughter declared a pretermitted child. She claimed that because the decedent executed the will before learning about the birth of his daughter, she was a pretermitted child. She further argued that because she was not legitimized until after the will, the daughter’s relationship with the father was akin to an adoption in 2002.

The son’s mother argued that by the plain reading of the statute, the daughter was not a pretermitted child because she was born after the decedent executed the Will.

Because the statute is clear and unambiguous, the court held that the daughter was not pretermitted because she was born prior to the decedent’s execution of the Will.  Moreover, the court found that decedent learning of the daughter’s birth later was not like an adoption because an “adjudication of paternity merely acknowledges an existing relationship.”

Additionally, the court held that even though the daughter was not explicitly mentioned in the Will, a class gift that included the daughter prevented any assertion that she was omitted, no matter how minimal her share of the class gift.

Practice Areas

i

Florida Trust Litigation

Our lawyers litigate disputes on behalf of beneficiaries, trustees, and other interested parties. He handles trust contests, trustee removal, and breach of trust actions. 

Florida Probate Litigation

Even the best estate planning can potentially spawn disagreements between beneficiaries, heirs, or other interested parties. We can assist in challenging an estate plan, defending a will contest, or lawsuits relating to personal representatives.

Fiduciary Litigation

We handle causes of action for breach of fiduciary duty relating to powers of attorney, caretakers, family members, trustees, and personal representatives.

Florida Securities Litigation

We have extensive experience in Florida representing customers against brokers, broker-dealers, investment advisors, and financial advisors.

Complex Commercial Litigation

We handle a broad range of business litigation matters including contract disputes, shareholder actions, and challenges to director or manager efforts.

Mediation

We understand alternative methods of resolving disputes. Our firm has civil mediators and can help with mediating a variety of civil litigation matters.

Our Team

Bob Persante

Bob Persante

Attorney

Bob is a trial lawyer in our Clearwater office handling securities litigation, complex business litigation, and estate litigation matters throughout Florida.

Zackary T. Zuroweste

Zackary T. Zuroweste

Attorney

Zack is a lawyer in our Clearwater office handling fiduciary litigation, trust & estate litigation, business litigation, and securities arbitrations.

Darren M. Stotts

Darren M. Stotts

Attorney

Darren is a lawyer in our Clearwater office. His practice areas include probate and trust litigation, fiduciary litigation, securities litigation, and commercial litigation matters.

Anastasia N. Landon

Anastasia N. Landon

Attorney

Anastasia is a lawyer in our Clearwater office. Her practice areas include probate and trust litigation, fiduciary litigation, securities litigation, and commercial litigation matters.

Cindy Corder

Cindy Corder

Litigation Paralegal/Mediation Coordinator

Susie Ross

Susie Ross

Litigation Paralegal

Sarah Greene

Sarah Greene

Litigation Paralegal

Finley

Finley

Firm Dog

Contact Us

Our law firm serves the Tampa Bay Area. We have two offices conveniently located in Clearwater and St. Petersburg. We handle matters in Pinellas, Pasco, and Hillsborough Counties. Please give us a call if you need assistance with a matter.

(727) 796-7666

2555 Enterprise Rd. Ste. 15, Clearwater, FL 33763

M-F: 8:30am-5:30pm, S-S: By Appointment Only

9 + 8 =